Space Exploration Merit Badge · Night 3 of 5
Missions
Requirements 5 and 6 — robotic vs crewed, and one vehicle in real detail
Choose a destination. Design the mission.
Monday, October 26, 2026
~30 min of slides + discussion in a 45-min block
Space Exploration Merit Badge · Night 3 of 5
Requirements 5 and 6 — robotic vs crewed, and one vehicle in real detail
Choose a destination. Design the mission.
You only have to do two of these three. Most Scouts should take 5a and 5c.
5a we do tonight, out loud, as a group. 5c you do on your own card, later tonight — it is a separate requirement from the base, and it is a robot, not a place people live.
Play 2–3 min of the vintage footage.
Without video: Voyager found active volcanoes on Io. Compare remote images and instrument readings with Apollo’s returned samples on the next comparison chart.
Backup Modern robotic alternative — great animation — How does a Mars Rover work? (Perseverance) (Jared Owen) ↗
Play 3–4 min.
Without video: Apollo 11 landed people on the Moon in 1969 and returned samples. Ask what a person can decide on the spot that a distant operator cannot.
Backup Modern crewed alternative — "Let's light this candle." — NASA SpaceX Crew Dragon Launch (C-SPAN) ↗
Try a flyby, then add a braking burn. Switch between the mission map and a Moon-facing cockpit camera. This simplified model illustrates Apollo navigation; it is not a reconstruction of the actual flight.
You are already in a 300 km circular orbit. One burn at the right moment stretches that circle until its far end reaches the Moon — and the Moon has to arrive at the same place at the same time.
Map: bodies and distances to scale · spacecraft marker enlarged · automatic lunar zoom
TRY THIS Compare “Fly past” with “Enter lunar orbit.” What does the braking burn change?
Teaching model, not an Apollo reconstruction. Earth + Moon gravity; circular lunar orbit at 384,400 km. Bodies and distances use the same map scale; the spacecraft marker is enlarged. The map zooms near the Moon. The cockpit camera faces the selected world. A real mission must also plan landing and return.
Clip only — 4 min from the launch-sequence section. Do not start it at 0:00 and hope.
Without video: Name the orbiter, external tank and two solid boosters. Explain launch, work in orbit, and the orbiter’s unpowered runway landing.
Backup Extra: Soyuz transport (does not replace an ISS purpose, operation and components discussion) — How does the Soyuz Launch work? (and Reentry) (Jared Owen) ↗
Imagine a budget that buys ten robotic missions or one crewed landing. Why might we still send people?
A thought experiment, not a measured cost ratio. Real costs depend on the mission.
Robots scout and measure; people interpret, choose, repair, and adapt on site. A team still has to justify its cost and risk.
Defend your choice: name a science goal, an advantage, and a tradeoff. Use a discovery from Voyager 1 or Apollo 11 as evidence.
Twelve people have stood on another world. Nobody has ever stayed. Your patrol is going to design the place that lets them stay.
That bootprint is still there. No wind, no rain, nothing to erase it.
Six boxes, five minutes, your own card. A robot that goes somewhere, picks something up, and brings it home. This is NOT the base you design in a minute — that one has people in it. This one is a round trip with nobody aboard.
CHALLENGE / Switch to lunar night. What fails first—and what restores it?
Patrols pick a location, then design a base and sell it in three minutes. Requirement 7 needs a drawing or model plus a plan for energy, construction, life support, and purpose. With a speaker: 15 minutes of design. Without: 30 minutes, and the drawings get genuinely good.